Burraton Field: Saltash Residents Challenge Aldi’s Plans at Crucial Public Meeting
Residents gathered at Saltash Wesley Church on Tuesday evening, 27 October, to hear Aldi’s updated proposals for a new supermarket on Burraton Field and question the company’s representatives. Afterwards, campaign group Save Saltash Green Spaces described the meeting as a positive opportunity to challenge the plans, while attendees raised further questions about traffic, the future of the playing field and the proposed replacement sports facilities.
The meeting, organised through Saltash Town Council’s Planning and Licensing Committee, brought the controversial proposal back into public discussion after months of debate about whether the site should become a supermarket or remain available for sport, recreation and community use.
For campaigners, the central issue is not simply whether Saltash needs another supermarket. It is whether building on Burraton Field is the right decision for the town, given the site’s existing recreational use and the consequences of losing open space.
Save Saltash Green Spaces welcomes residents’ involvement
Following the meeting, Save Saltash Green Spaces posted a message thanking residents for attending.
The group said:
“Thank you to the residents of saltash for turning up tonight, it was a long shift and we believe it has been very positive opportunity.”
The post attracted comments from residents thanking campaigners for their work and discussing the presentation.
Some attendees questioned the strength of Aldi’s case. One commenter described the presentations as poorly prepared, while another said the case appeared weak. These are personal assessments from people who attended, rather than independent findings about the quality of the presentation.
Town councillor Scott Slavin also commented that there had been “some interesting discussion”.
However, the campaign group’s initial post did not set out the detailed questions asked, the answers given by Aldi’s representatives or any formal outcome.
The meeting should therefore be seen as an opportunity for scrutiny, rather than evidence that the development has been approved, rejected or stopped.
What is Aldi proposing for Burraton Field?

Aldi’s proposal is for a new supermarket on land west of Callington Road in Saltash.
The company says the development would represent an investment of approximately £10 million and create around 40 local jobs. Its plans also include free customer parking, electric vehicle charging provision, landscaping and a new community food store.
Aldi argues that a local store could improve access to affordable food and reduce the need for some residents to travel to supermarkets further afield.
The proposed store would have more than 100 parking spaces, including accessible and parent-and-child bays. Aldi also anticipates around three to four deliveries a day, with deliveries planned outside peak traffic hours where possible.
These are the developer’s stated benefits and operating assumptions. Their implications for the local road network and neighbouring communities still need to be assessed through the planning process.
Source: Aldi’s proposals for Saltash.
The consultation showed substantial opposition
The updated proposals follow a public consultation held between 14 January and 4 February 2026.
According to the consultation figures reported before Tuesday’s meeting, 1,492 feedback forms were received.
Of those respondents:
- 857 opposed the proposal in principle.
- 487 supported it.
- 113 were unsure.
Those figures show that opposition to the development was substantial among people who responded.
However, the answers were not entirely uniform. When asked whether a new Aldi store would benefit the area, 637 respondents answered yes and 660 answered no, with others unsure.
That distinction matters. Some residents may welcome the arrival of Aldi while opposing the choice of site. The debate is therefore about both the potential benefits of a new supermarket and the consequences of building it on this particular piece of land.
Source: Voice Newspapers — Aldi supermarket proposals back on the agenda in Saltash.
The replacement pitch: the key question
One of the most important elements of Aldi’s updated proposal is its plan to fund a full-size, floodlit 3G football and rugby pitch at Saltash Community School.
Aldi says it explored a like-for-like replacement for the existing playing field but found suitable land difficult to identify. Its preferred alternative is an all-weather pitch that could be used by pupils during the school day and local sports clubs outside school hours.
The company estimates that the existing Burraton pitch provides around 1.5 hours of weekly match capacity, compared with 34 modelled peak-period hours for the proposed 3G facility.
Those figures are Aldi’s assessment of the relative capacity of the facilities. They do not, on their own, settle whether the proposed replacement would meet the needs of the clubs, young people and wider community who currently use Burraton Field.
There are several practical questions that need answering:
- Would the replacement facility be available to local clubs at the times they need it?
- How would access and booking arrangements work outside school hours?
- Would the new pitch provide equivalent or better quality and accessibility?
- What would happen to the existing users of Burraton Field during any transition?
- Who would be responsible for maintaining and operating the replacement facility over the long term?
Planning policy requires the loss of a playing field to be replaced by equivalent or better provision in terms of quantity and quality, with comparable or improved accessibility for the community.
The details of the proposed replacement, rather than simply its headline capacity, will therefore be important in assessing the development.
Traffic remains a major concern
Traffic is another issue residents want addressed.
Aldi says it has undertaken additional traffic surveys and is preparing a Transport Assessment using a methodology agreed with the highways authority. Cornwall Highways is expected to review the proposals and advise whether mitigation measures are required.
The developer argues that a new store could reduce some longer journeys to supermarkets elsewhere.
But residents have questioned whether a supermarket on this site would add traffic to Callington Road and nearby junctions, and how the effects of customer journeys, deliveries and other movements would be managed.
One resident responding to the campaign group’s post specifically asked what Aldi’s traffic plan involved.
The answer needs to come from the transport evidence and the assessment by the relevant highways authority. Without the completed assessment and its conclusions, it would be premature to say that traffic will improve or that the development will necessarily cause unacceptable congestion.
The same principle applies to drainage. Aldi says further drainage work has been undertaken, but the technical evidence and the conclusions of the relevant consultees will be important.
Who owns Burraton Field, and can the development proceed?
Questions about ownership have also surfaced in the public discussion.
A resident commenting on the Save Saltash Green Spaces post asked how Cornwall Council came to own the land, while another raised the question of Aldi purchasing land on which planning permission might not be granted.
Aldi’s own published proposals state that it has exchanged contracts to buy the site from Cornwall Council.
A land purchase and planning permission are separate matters. Exchanging contracts does not, by itself, grant permission to build a supermarket.
Cornwall Council’s disposal of the land has also been discussed in Saltash Town Council papers. A report presented to the town council in February 2026 explained that the land had not been declared surplus when Aldi first approached Cornwall Council and described the circumstances surrounding the disposal process.
The council report also stated that Aldi would only receive planning consent if sporting provision in Saltash was maintained or improved.
The important distinction is that the ownership question, the decision to dispose of land and the planning decision are related but separate issues. The planning authority must still consider the application against the relevant planning policies and evidence.
Source: Saltash Town Council — February 2026 papers.
Why the rugby club’s position matters
Burraton Field has a history of recreational use, including use by young players associated with Saltash Rugby Football Club.
In a statement published in January 2026, the club said it was not opposed to Aldi as a retailer but believed the supermarket would be better located elsewhere.
The club raised concerns about losing valuable green space, the effect on its future development, drainage, access and potential additional parking pressures around Moorlands Lane and Smithy Close.
The club also explained that it had previously been interested in taking on the maintenance and development of the football pitch, but that this arrangement did not proceed after Aldi expressed an interest in the land.
The club’s statement represents its own position, but it highlights why the replacement pitch is such an important part of the wider debate.
The issue is not only how much playing capacity might be created elsewhere. It is also whether existing clubs and residents would lose a familiar, accessible space and whether the proposed alternative would meet their practical needs.
Source: Saltash RFC — statement on the Aldi proposal at Lower Burraton Field.
What happens after Tuesday’s meeting?
The extraordinary meeting was arranged to hear a presentation from Cavendish Consulting, acting on Aldi’s behalf, followed by a 20-minute period for public questions, comments and representations.
It was not a meeting to determine a planning application.
Before the meeting, Aldi’s updated proposals were expected to inform a future planning application, with the company anticipating submission in November 2026. That was the timetable stated in the material available before the meeting, not a confirmed submission date.
The planning process will need to consider the application and supporting evidence, including the implications for the playing field, replacement sports provision, highways, drainage and other relevant planning matters.
As of this article’s preparation, the campaign group’s public post confirms that the meeting took place and that it considered the opportunity positive. It does not provide a verified record of the detailed discussion or any formal decision made afterwards.
The next important step is to establish what was said in response to residents’ questions and what further work, if any, Aldi or the council has committed to undertaking.
A decision with long-term consequences for Saltash
Burraton Field has become a wider debate about how Saltash balances development with the protection of community assets.
Aldi has presented a case based on investment, employment, shopping choice and replacement sports provision. Opponents argue that the proposed location would sacrifice existing green space and recreational land, and that the promised benefits must be weighed against the lasting consequences.
Both the supermarket proposal and the campaign against it deserve to be assessed against the evidence rather than assumptions.
For residents, the crucial questions remain straightforward: can the loss of Burraton Field be justified, will the replacement sports facilities genuinely meet community needs, and can the traffic and drainage implications be satisfactorily addressed?
Tuesday’s meeting gave residents another opportunity to put those questions directly to the developer.
The next stage is to find out what answers were provided — and how those answers will be reflected in the planning process.
Sources and further reading
- Saltash Town Council — extraordinary Planning and Licensing Committee agenda, 27 October 2026
- Aldi — proposals for Saltash
- Voice Newspapers — updated proposals and consultation results
- Saltash Rugby Club — its position on the proposed development
- Saltash Town Council — February 2026 papers on Burraton Field
In Saltash News will update this report when a fuller account of the meeting and any subsequent council records become available.

